A 70-Ring Gordo Joins the Brick House Maduro Lineup
J.C. Newman Cigar Co. has put the thickest cigar in the history of its Brick House Maduro line on retailer shelves. The Brick House Maduro Commodore, also styled The Commodore, is a 5 1/2 x 70 gordo, and it is offered at a suggested retail price of $11.50 per cigar. It comes in boxes of 25 and in bags of five, a pair of formats that lets a shop sell it either as a commitment or as a single-evening trial.
The Commodore was first shown at the Premium Cigar Association trade show in New Orleans in April 2026, and Cigar Aficionado reported at the time that it was scheduled to ship June 1. Halfwheel's first report likewise said the cigar was expected to ship in June. By July, Cigar Dojo reported that J.C. Newman had begun shipping the cigar, citing a company press release dated July 22, 2026. Halfwheel followed with its own note that the company was shipping the Commodore. Anyone who saw the cigar on the show floor in the spring and then went looking for it at the counter can read that timeline as the gap between a trade-show debut and the point at which boxes actually reach lounges and online retailers.
For now, the Commodore exists only in the Maduro version of Brick House. Halfwheel noted that J.C. Newman had not announced plans to add the size to the standard Brick House line or other blends, and that the 6 1/4 x 60 Mighty Mighty remains the thickest vitola in the regular Brick House range.
What Is Inside: Blend and Construction
The blend follows the rest of the Maduro line. The wrapper is Brazilian Arapiraca, set over a Nicaraguan binder and Nicaraguan fillers. J.C. Newman rolls the Brick House cigars at its PENSA factory in Estelí, Nicaragua. According to the company's own description of the family, the Maduro is the full-strength member of the brand, with sweetness that comes from its fermented wrapper. The Classic Brick House, by comparison, is described as medium in strength, wrapped in an Ecuadorian-grown Havana-seed leaf, and the Double Connecticut is described as mild.
Why Arapiraca Matters
Arapiraca is a tobacco-growing region in Brazil's northeastern state of Alagoas, and leaf from that region has long been a go-to for makers who want a dark, oily maduro wrapper with natural sweetness. Fermenting the leaf for extended periods darkens it and draws out sugars, which is the usual explanation for the cocoa and sweet-spice impressions smokers associate with the style. The Commodore's published blend does not change that formula. What changes is the stage the formula performs on: a 70-ring-gauge cigar carries far more filler tobacco than a robusto, and the wrapper stretches over a much wider barrel.
A Different Burn Profile
Ring gauge is measured in sixty-fourths of an inch, so a 70-gauge cigar is a little more than an inch across. In a short cigar of that width, the ember is broad and the distance between the lit end and the smoker's mouth is modest. Most cigar makers, J.C. Newman included, will tell a prospective buyer that this geometry usually cools the smoke and slows the burn relative to a thinner cigar. The company is leaning on that idea in its own marketing: despite the 5 1/2-inch length, it says the Commodore is built for a smoke of about three hours.
That claim is worth a note for anyone planning an evening around it. A three-hour cigar is an investment of time that suits a patio chair, a long game on the television or a slow Saturday, rather than a quick break at lunch. It is also a reminder that the Commodore is aimed at a particular kind of smoker, one who does not mind giving up an afternoon to a single cigar.
The Mighty Mighty Connection
The reasoning behind the new size comes straight from the company's best seller. Fourth-generation owner Drew Newman told Cigar Aficionado: "Our most popular Brick House size is the 6 1/4-by-60 Mighty Mighty." He added a production figure to underline the point: "This year, we will hand roll 1.1 million cigars in that vitola alone."
Newman then described the new cigar in family terms. "The Commodore is Mighty Mighty's big brother," he said, and the magazine quoted him saying that its standard 5 1/2-inch length makes it more approachable than the typical 7 by 70. In the company's July announcement, Cigar Dojo described the Commodore as a shorter alternative to the Mighty Mighty, which captures the odd arithmetic of the size: it is shorter than the Mighty Mighty, but wider, so it presents more cigar in the hand while taking up less room in the humidor.
The company also gave the cigar a nautical identity. "When you light The Commodore, you take command," Newman said. "As captain of your ship, prepare to set sail on a bold three-hour cigar journey." The name suits a boxy, broad-shouldered gordo, and it offers a break from the strictly architectural vocabulary of the rest of the line.
Where the Commodore Sits in the Brick House Catalog
With the Commodore added, the Maduro line now lists four sizes: the Commodore at 5 1/2 x 70, the Mighty Mighty at 6 1/4 x 60, the Toro at 6 x 52 and the Robusto at 5 x 54. Cigar Aficionado noted that the Commodore brought the Maduro range to four sizes. The broader Brick House catalog is bigger. The Classic line lists nine sizes, ranging from the Teaser at 3 1/2 x 56 to the Churchill at 7 1/4 x 50, along with an aluminum-tube Traveler. The Double Connecticut offers six sizes, and the Bricktoberfest, a limited edition built to go with an Oktoberfest-style lager, is a 7 3/4 x 48 Churchill with a pigtail head.
At $11.50, the Commodore sits at the high end of the Maduro offerings, which fits the quantity of tobacco in the cigar. The company has built its reputation on value, and Drew Newman's own description of the brand reads that way: "Brick House is known around the world for its outstanding taste, flawless construction, and excellent value," he said in the release covered by Cigar Dojo. An eleven-and-a-half dollar price puts the Commodore in a middle band for a premium cigar of this heft. It is a cigar to buy by the bag if a smoker wants to see whether the size agrees with him before committing to a box.
A Brand With Roots in a Hungarian Village
Brick House has more history behind it than most new vitolas can claim. The company says Julius Newman introduced the brand in 1937 and named it for the house where he was born, the only brick house in his small Hungarian village. In the company's telling, it was the place where family, friends and neighbors gathered nightly to enjoy one another's company. More than eight decades later, third-generation owners Eric and Bobby Newman reintroduced the cigars, and the brand has since built a following well beyond the family's home market.
J.C. Newman itself is one of the older family-run names in American cigars, and Drew Newman is the fourth generation to run it. The Commodore is a continuation of that approach. It is a bigger cigar for a bigger-ring-gauge market from a brand that has already proved it can sell volume.
Critical Standing
The brand has a record with the major publications. J.C. Newman lists Brick House in the Cigar Aficionado Top 25 Cigars of the Year at No. 10 in 2024, No. 23 in 2022, No. 17 in 2016 and No. 17 in 2010. The company also lists a 91 from Cigar Aficionado for the Brick House Maduro Robusto and a 93 from Cigar & Spirits. Those scores apply to other sizes, not to the Commodore. As of this writing, a full published review of the Commodore itself was not among the coverage found, so smokers wanting to know how the wide ring gauge changes the flavor will have to rely on their own experience or wait for reviewers to catch up.
Why Big Ring Gauges Keep Coming
Cigar Aficionado framed the release as part of a longer shift in the market, writing that "the once-excessive 60 ring gauge has left novelty status behind and has become standard in today's market." On that reading, J.C. Newman is not so much chasing a trend as acknowledging one that has already settled in. A manufacturer that sells more than a million Mighty Mighty cigars in a year knows what its customers are asking for at the counter, and a larger gauge is a logical next step.
There is also a practical argument for the Commodore's proportions. Gordo-style cigars of 70 or more have a reputation in some quarters for being unwieldy, partly because they are so often rolled long, at 6 or 7 inches. A 5 1/2-inch cigar with the same girth has less distance for the smoker to manage between the foot and the ash tray, and it avoids the top-heavy feel of a longer cigar of the same diameter. Newman's remark that the standard length makes it more approachable than the typical 7 by 70 speaks to that point directly.
What It Means for Retailers
For shops, the two package options matter. Boxes of 25 suit regulars who already smoke the Mighty Mighty and want a second shape in the rotation. Five-count bags are the easier entry for someone who has never tried a 70-gauge cigar. The Maduro line has the attraction of a recognizable name, and the Commodore gives the sales floor a new item. Because the cigar is currently a Maduro-only size, a retailer cannot offer the same shape in the milder Classic or Double Connecticut blends. That keeps the Commodore firmly in the category of full-bodied cigars, and it narrows the audience to smokers who are comfortable with a dark wrapper and a heavy dose of sweetness.
Who Should Reach for a Commodore
The Commodore is a good fit for a smoker who already likes the Brick House Maduro and wants something with more tobacco and a longer burn. It will suit someone who has the time. By the company's own estimate it takes about three hours, so it is not a weekday-commute cigar. It also suits a smoker looking for a maduro that does not carry the weight of a seven-inch gordo.
The pairing options are the usual ones for a sweet maduro: dark rum, bourbon, a stout or a strong black coffee. Because the cigar is full-strength, many experienced smokers recommend having something to eat first. None of that is a claim about the Commodore's specific flavor, since reviewers have yet to publish detailed notes. It is simply a sensible approach to a full-bodied cigar that will occupy the better part of an evening.
For collectors, the Commodore is a modest proposition. It is a regular-production item, not a limited release, and nothing in the announcements suggests that availability will be restricted. Anyone interested in the first production boxes can still find them listed with online retailers, though stock levels will vary from shop to shop. Those who like to track a brand's evolution may be more interested in what happens next: whether the Commodore remains a Maduro exclusive, or whether J.C. Newman eventually brings the size to the Classic or Double Connecticut lines. For now the company has not said.
The Quick Reference
The facts as reported by halfwheel, Cigar Aficionado and Cigar Dojo are consistent. The cigar is the Brick House Maduro Commodore, also called Brick House The Commodore Maduro. It measures 5 1/2 x 70 and is classed as a gordo. The wrapper is Brazilian Arapiraca, the binder and fillers are Nicaraguan, and the factory is J.C. Newman's PENSA facility in Estelí. The suggested retail price is $11.50, and the packaging is boxes of 25 or bags of five. It debuted at the PCA show in April 2026, was slated for a June 1 ship date, and was reported as shipping by July. The company says to plan on about three hours of smoking time.
The Commodore will not reinvent Brick House. What it does is extend a successful brand into a size that the market has been moving toward for years, using a blend that smokers already know. Whether the 70 ring gauge improves on the Mighty Mighty will come down to the cigar itself, and the first wave of reviews should settle that argument over the coming months.